Skip to main content

Barnum Effect - Brief Personal Reflection


The Barnum Effect "a little something for everyone".

Psychometric tests consist of Barnum Effect, which imply generalization, and human are likely to fall into the trap. The classic example will be personality test. A set of personality-related items have been administered, and the subjects are likely to accept the result describing their personality.

As I recalled few years back, my participants are very pleased with the personality test. Most of them agree with the interpretation. How reliable and valid of the test? Personally, I believe it is just the trick of test.

We can never realize that explanation of our personality traits always lay in every domain. The only discussion is to discover which trait you are most prominent, and being told that each of us have all the traits which qualified as less prominent. Therefore, it is likely to be accepted.

Implication of psychometric tests is effective across context such as education setting, workforce or counselling sessions. Nonetheless, it is undeniable that they serve as basic guideline to further in depth understanding human traits. I admit that prior understanding of traits is essential to ease the process of forming contact with one another.

I believe that it is reliable yet validity is questionable. It is not content specific, yet it is domain general. Domain generality doesn't have specific object or mechanism to be focused on. It is just similar as learning. Learning is just a label, it doesn't content any information about what we learn, how we learn, what is the function of learning and etc.

Barnum effect is the newly term for me. I don't regard it as faulty or wrong, in fact it gives me hope, in provided I am not over indulged in it.

Psychology is just a Barnum effect, it gives justification for human thought, behavior and affect. It gives a free will for human to believe in what they believe. Psychology is an infinite variation, presents in every scent of life, which also makes psychology so attractive.

p/s: Barnum Effect is not only applied to personality test, it applies to horoscope, palm reading, tarot cards and so on.

Hui Ru

Comments

  1. i heard of Barnum effect before! :)
    i think i also have this effect on myself =x

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

当你爱的人伤害自己 心痛的是爱你的那个人 就好像眼睁睁的看着爱的人走向火堆 再怎样的担忧爱的人还是继续走向 爱的人和爱你的人都各自有主见 但那个方式才是对才是错 跟着爱的人的方式 明明就觉得危险但还需要装作不危险 还是要告诉爱的人危险但爱的人不想知道危险 这就是困难之处 难道真的不做任何努力挽救? 就这样默默让爱的人要怎样就怎样? 理不清对错 爱中不讲理 爱只所以强大是因为真的很难
累计的事件与情绪,不要认为不谈就过去 其实就是吨积,直到忍不住就会爆发 内心是一个小剧场 心里很忐忑,很不平和 甚至有气愤,无奈,很难过 其实就是延生来 心中很抗拒一句话 别打扰你 还有评判接受到的信息 期望我选择独处的时候,对方是接纳的 而不是造成对方不舒服 知道对方是不舒服的,自己也给自己负担 压力下的互动品质特差 深怕我任何的话语再次造成伤害 而我自己情绪状态不好之下,整个过程变得很尬 我潜意识下,我也不知觉做了伤害动作 我到现在才知道 我对别人来说是个地雷 期望别人能够接纳同理我现实状况,逗我笑给我正面力量,但这个要求也许是不合理 我不够好的一面,好像是需要藏起来的 这让我很自卑,自责,因为显现了变成了困扰 我自己也焦虑吧,也表现出没事却也有事 我害怕做自己是被审判被厌烦 写这写这,我理清自己我慢慢变平和了。
Recently learnt about emotion triangle, it said human tends to suppress core emotion, and manifested as either a defense or inhibitory emotion. The emotion that we tends to inhibit are shame, guilt ... There are fear and inferiority that governs my heart - I have to learn to address and admit my feelings better, and make a decision to communicate or set a boundary. It is hard to actually do so, and I know after I have done it - I can sense my guilt and shame. It is like a vicious cycle.  I have to make a promise to myself - be mindful, be steady and let my head clears. Don't react much...But at the same times I am glad that I did say something. I did express myself. I did feeling less intense. I treated it as a progress.  Anyway I felt sorry of the people that I hurt - when I am still a human with sin...